Tuchel undone by basic errors as PSG cement bad reputation
March 7, 2019
No matter how much certain clubs change coaches, players or owners, traces of identity tend to linger.
On Wednesday, Manchester United, a club with a history of dramatic and unlikely late European comebacks, played their role to dramatic perfection as they unseated opponents who have developed a reputation for snatching defeat not from the jaws, but from the throat, of victory.
Two years after they blew a 4-0 first leg lead to lose 6-5 on aggregate to Barcelona, Thomas Tuchel's Paris Saint-Germain made unwanted history as the first side in Europe's biggest club competition to go out after winning their first leg 2-0 away from home. They were the 107th side to face such a situation.
Familiar story for German coach
Marcus Rashford's injury time spot kick, controversially awarded after a VAR decision Tuchel described as "cruel", broke Parisian hearts after mistakes from German defender Thilo Kehrer and Gianluigi Buffon had gifted Romelu Lukaku two first half goals that sandwiched a Juan Bernat strike.
“In the second half, they didn’t have a single chance," said Tuchel after the game. "I have no explanation.”
It was a reaction almost identical to that which Tuchel had when his Borussia Dortmund side conceded three late goals to Liverpool to throw away a Europa League quarterfinal in 2016 but, unlike that night, the blame perhaps falls more heavily on the players.
The two defensive blunders, as well as a rare off night in front of goal for Kylian Mbappe, go some way to explaining what the former Mainz boss cannot. But his is not a position where excuses are easily accepted and he will have to accept his share of the fallout.
Unai Emery was out of a job a year or so after the Barcelona collapse and defeat to a United side missing 10 first teamers including Paul Pogba and Anthony Martial will inevitably lead to speculation about Tuchels' future. Such is the nature of the PSG job under its Qatari owners. Domestic dominance is a given, only European glory will do.
Before the game, Tuchel spoke about his opposite number, who famously scored an injury time winner to seal a dramatic turnaround in Manchester United's favor against Bayern Munich in the 1999 final
United leave it late again
“It’s better to always be aware of the qualities of Ole Gunnar Solskjær,” Tuchel said. “He was one of the key players of the biggest era of this club. He was always ready to help, in 30 minutes, 20 mins, 10 or five. This is the spirit of Manchester United, that they are ready for anything."
On Wednesday, those words proved prophetic. And they also shone a harsh light on the players he's largely inherited, who once again weren't able to handle the pressure that comes with expectation.
"Kehrer was not in Barcelona, Gigi (Buffon) was not in Barcelona, I was not in Barcelona, so I think it's too easy to put it on this," Tuchel said after the game, referring to the 1999 final.
Tuchel needs time to instill the precise methods and style that made his reputation and in the first leg of this tie, it looked like he had managed to create a tactical awareness and discipline PSG had often lacked.
But despite responding to well to an early setback, it seems there's plenty of work still to do. Those traces of identity don't wash away so easily after all.