EU split on top job appointments
June 21, 2019
Leaders of the European Union's member states on Thursday struggled to break the deadlock over the bloc's key leadership positions.
Heads of government were gathered to decide on five top jobs — most notably who should succeed Jean-Claude Juncker as the next president of the European Commission, the EU's executive branch.
But despite talks extending into the early hours of Friday, the leaders deferred any decision on the posts until June 30.
"There was no majority on any candidate," said EU Council President Donald Tusk. "The European Council agreed that there has to be a package reflecting the diversity of the EU."
Juncker himself said he was confident that a solution would be found, although the task would not be easy. "I don't expect that. But it has to be done," said Juncker.
Favorite to replace Juncker is German EU lawmaker Manfred Weber, whose center-right European People's Party (EPP) is the largest grouping in the European Parliament. However, the EPP lost seats in last month's European elections, making it more difficult to form a majority in parliament that would be in favor of the Bavarian.
Read more: Manfred Weber: Merkel's pick to head European Commission
Ahead of the meeting, German Chancellor Angela Merkel and French President Emmanuel Macron said they were in favor of a delay to avoid any hasty decisions being made.
After the meeting, Merkel expressed concern that there appeared to be no clear majority in favor of Weber in the European Parliament, which must still ratify the appointments.
"It is a finding that presents us with challenges, of course, that is clear," Merkel said, stressing the importance of a "balanced" package of appointments that would find agreement. "Under no circumstances do we want a crisis with the parliament."
What other roles are up for grabs?
EU leaders must decide on successors to Tusk, and to Federica Mogherini, the bloc's foreign policy chief.
They'll also be choosing a new head of the European Central Bank (ECB) to replace current incumbent Mario Draghi, and the successor to Antonio Tajani, the president of the European Parliament.
Why is it proving so difficult?
The process of choosing people for the top jobs is far from straightforward.
According to Irish Prime Minister Leo Varadkar: "It's quicker to elect the pope, very often, than it is to fill these particular positions."
Because of the complexity, the process is often criticized for the horse-trading that takes place behind closed doors, and the length of time it takes. It involves both the European Parliament and member states:
- Firstly, groups in the European Parliament are asked to put forward their lead candidates for consideration by European leaders in the European Council.
- Leaders initially consider the lead candidate of the largest group in the parliament — who they can reject — then the second largest, and so on.
- If the European Council can agree on a candidate, the European Parliament is asked to vote by a majority in favor of the appointment.
- The Parliament could always reject the nominee, and the process starts all over again.
Several elements need to be considered to find a solution that will satisfy everyone.
Party politics: There's keen competition between the conservative EPP, the Socialists, free-market liberals and even the Greens, to ensure their concerns are reflected by different EU institutions.
Read more: No new dawn for far right in European election
With the European parliament more divided than ever after mainstream parties lost ground at the European elections, smaller groupings can now exert more influence, making the process of negotiation more complex.
Nationality: While leaders of EU institutions are not supposed to show favor to their home countries, national pride still plays a role when the top appointments are made. Individual governments are keen to press for their own politicians — provided they are of a similar political hue — to be at the helm.
Gender: The leadership of the EU reflects the domestic politics of member states, with men taking most of the top roles. Macron and Tusk are among those demanding that at least two women be chosen for the most important jobs this time around.
Geography: Ideally, there should also be a mix of large member states – like Germany and France — and smaller ones such as Juncker's Luxembourg. The package should also reflect the diversity of the bloc. At present, it's a little lopsided with three out of the five roles filled by Italians.
rc/aw (AFP, AP, dpa)