How does climate change affect El Nino and La Nina cycles?
January 27, 2023
If winds slow down over the Pacific Ocean, they will set a chain of events in motion that could see heavy rains batter California, heat waves roast Europe and droughts kill crops in countries from Brazil to Indonesia.
That is what some scientists expect to happen in 2023, though they caution that they won't know for sure until May. A study published Wednesday, which uses established methods but has not yet been peer-reviewed, estimates the hot weather pattern El Nino has about a 90% chance of returning this year.
"We forecast that it will be a moderate to strong event — over 1.5 degrees Celsius (2.7 degrees Fahrenheit)," said Josef Ludescher, a scientist at the Potsdam Institute for Climate Impact Research in Germany and lead author of the study.
Such a shift — coming off the back of three years of the cold weather pattern La Nina — would make heat waves hotter and disrupt weather patterns across the world. Scientists have long struggled to work out what role global warming plays.
"El Nino is responsible for a lot of extremes," said Regina Rodrigues, an oceanographer at the Federal University of Santa Catarina in Brazil, who was not involved in the study. "Every country, in one way or another, is affected."
What are El Nino and La Nina and how do they work?
El Nino and La Nina are names for complex wind and temperature patterns in the Pacific Ocean. The winds in the ocean can take one of three phases. One is neutral, where they blow east to west. Another is El Nino, where they slow down or even stop. And then there is La Nina, where they blow stronger.
You can think of the Pacific Ocean, which covers one-third of the Earth, as a bathtub of cold water with a fan near the taps. Twist open the hot tap for a few seconds and turn on the fan, and the breeze will blow a stream of warm water from the tap to the end of the tub. In normal years, this is how winds push heat from South America to Asia.
But, during El Nino, changes in heat and pressure stop the fan from blowing. Hot water sloshes back toward the taps, leaving more warm water in the middle of the tub — or, to move away from the analogy, the ocean and near South America. That makes it more likely to evaporate and form rain clouds in places they are not normally expected.
"All of a sudden, you could get massive amounts of rain near the coast of Peru," said Erin Coughlan de Perez, an author of the latest Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change report and scientist with the Red Cross Climate Center. "It's just unprecedented dumps of water in a place that is usually pretty dry."
The effects of El Nino stretch high above the Pacific Ocean and across the Earth. They alter the path of jet streams — strong winds far above the ground — that travel the planet guiding rains.
"The high clouds poke the atmosphere and trigger [atmospheric] waves," Rodrigues said. "That disrupts the climate everywhere."
Does climate change cause El Nino and La Nina?
El Nino and La Nina are natural phenomena. Scientists don't fully understand what causes them, but they know from coral reefs and tree rings that they have always varied.
There is some evidence that they have gotten stronger — the strongest El Nino events recorded have taken place in the past few decades — but it is unclear if this is just chance.
The IPCC, a scientific body that regularly evaluates peer-reviewed research on climate change, found that there is "low confidence" that global warming has already changed El Nino events. Some computer models show El Nino getting stronger in the future, while others see it getting weaker.
But the IPCC also found the effects of extreme El Nino and La Nina events are likely to hit harder as the planet heats up.
Since warmer air can take up more moisture, the same El Nino event means that more rain falls locally, Ludescher said. The air can hold 7% more water vapor for every 1 degree Celsius the planet heats. By burning fossil fuels and destroying forests, humanity has heated the planet 1.2 degrees Celsius since the Industrial Revolution.
Do El Nino and La Nina make climate change worse?
Global surface temperatures rise by about 0.1 degree Celsius during El Nino years. In La Nina years, they fall by about the same amount. This is because less cold water is pulled up from the deep ocean near Peru during El Nino, leaving more warm water at the surface. This pushes surface temperatures higher.
If El Nino returns in 2023, global average temperatures could pass 1.5 degrees Celsius — the level to which world leaders promised to try to hold global warming by the end of the century.
Still, a spike in temperatures from El Nino would not make humanity less likely to meet its long-term climate targets, which depend on cutting greenhouse gas pollution. But the extra heat, in the short term, would hurt people, plants and animals.
Coral reefs, for instance, are expected to decline 70-90% if global warming passes 1.5 degrees Celsius. Passing that threshold even briefly could have permanent consequences. "Some corals may not survive this. And if they are dead, they don't come back," said Ludescher.
Why do El Nino and La Nina matter?
Many seasonal weather forecasts rely on correctly predicting the phase — and strength — of El Nino and La Nina. The information can help everyone from city planners to farmers.
"This isn't just theoretically interesting: This is useful information," Coughlan de Perez said. For instance, local governments could make early warning plans for heat waves and create systems to protect elderly residents, who are at greater risk of dying.
"This is about us and our preparation and how we survive in a warming world," Coughlan de Perez said.
Edited by: Jennifer Collins